The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 597 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
I absolutely love this. I think you handled the topic in a great way and I know many people who have changed their views on this and other subjects over the past decade or two. I think it's great to see both sides and try to understand people. I really appreciate the thought and courage that went into writing and submitting this entry. You definitely nailed the topic and made me stop and think.
07/13/23
I appreciate your take on the topic. I knew this would be a contentious week! It is well-written and gives a different perspective. But I do think the argument is facile, and fixing a heart is COMPLETELY different to major reassignment surgery with its long-term health issues that are now coming to light. You do not change the structure and function of a heart - you do both with reassignment surgery.

Many, many girls feel uncomfortable with their bodies. I HATED dresses and didn't start wearing them until I was in my 20s. If you told 13-15-year old me that I was the wrong gender, I might have believed you. But that is a case of learning to love and accept who God created to you to be - not who you think He made you to be.

I may disagree with your story, but that's the whole point of this topic, so well done!
07/13/23
Thank so much for your bravery in writing this. I can tell you are expressing what's in your heart and I applaud you for your honesty.

Even someone's feelings are wrong and misguided, having them dismissed without any discussion can be counterproductive if we hope to welcome people to the love of God.

I am not suggesting a Biblical compromise. But, perhaps, a willingness to listen and then let God sort out the challenges.
07/22/23
Hmmm. Thank you for your bravely in writing the Gender topic from another angle. The story flow was well written.

Having said that, I MUST DISAGREE with your perspective on Gender. My worry is that you use scriptures to back up your argument and even describe God in female gender. It is important to interpret scripture in context and not infer your own meaning into scripture. We are to fashion our lives to scripture not the other way round. You say God is possibly both gender or no gender. This is scripturally wrong. God is always referred in scripture in the masculine analogy hence we pray - OUR FATHER. Unfortunately exposing this will take too long to write here but perhaps my comment will make some study scripture better with a good Bible commentary. This article may also help-https://www.gotquestions.org/God-the-mother.html

Likewise I must say that those who speak against these gender struggles are not necessarily unloving or critical as your story portrays. Rather it is more unloving not to tell people the consequence of their decisions and where it will lead. See my entry again - "A practical experiment with Gender". I have not shared my personal story in this entry but I will say a bit now- if Jesus did not save me, I was already on the Lesbian lifestyle pathway because I was growing up with hatred for men as my dad abused my mum. Like Corinne said above most of these struggles are linked to childhood identity crisis which the Lord can heal as we grow into adulthood. Jesus breaks every chain. For me knowing Jesus healed the pain of Childhood and today God has blessed me with a Godly family. Jesus can do this for anyone too.

Thank you, Sister, for writing. Keep writing.