The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 297 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
I enjoyed the message of this story and can relate to it a great deal. My sister and I have had similiar conversations. My three kids all chose professions that made them happy, served others, but didn't pay as well. My sister's kids were more focused on finding well-paying jobs.

I'd urge you to write everything that comes to mind and then go back and do a lot of tightening and editing. For example, I might edit beginning like this: In the foyer, after church, my friend Malvin was discussing career plans with college student, Jason.
Just those little tweaks removed about half of the words, but still set up the scene. The other thing is the dialog doesn't feel authentic. Don't be afraid to use body language and thoughts along with dialog.
For example: Jason shoved his hands in his pockets. "Do you think God should choose our careers?"
Malvin stroked his chin, pausing before answering. "Seems like there's a verse that might answer your question." He picked up his Bible, flipped through the pages, and said, "Ah, here it is. Roman's 8:30. 'And those he predestined... glorified.' What do you think that means? Should you pick a career that pays good or one where you can glorify God?"
That's just a quick example to show one way to make it feel more realistic. Having him use body language and read from Bible feels more natural to me, especially in a casual conversation.
I like the message and I think you've a great foundation built, it just needs some tweaking to make it more natural, body language to show emotions, and if you tighten it up and take out unnecessary words, it will leave you more words to show and not tell. I like the ending. It brings it full circle. Often people are drawn to stories when the kid (or underdog) comes to the right answer themselves with gentle guiding from the other MC. It can be more relatable that way. Your ending was a great message.
05/25/21
Oh, I enjoyed this so much!
Powerful message, and on topic. I especially loved how you wrapped it up with this final line:

"Malvin, “All I will have when I leave this world is my relationship to Christ. We are here for a purpose, don’t miss your calling.”


Blessings~
05/26/21
Great message from the perspective of an eavesdropper, however it would have been easier for me to follow in the first person.

From the you yourself as the main character, 'Malvin' or from Jason's perspective.

The reason I'm giving this advise is because I needed to go back a few times to see where 'you' fit in to the conversation before realizing you were repeating something you had overheard, which can complicate tenses/voice and points of view.

If I'm incorrect can another seasoned writer help me unwind my suggestion?

Again please let me reiterate, the foundation of your message was great.