The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 801 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
10/30/14
Awwww. So glad for the happy ending. I was upset when the the MC's dog went into the ocean...I was hoping for my happy ending. I'm such a mushy individual, and love happy endings. Thanks for this one!

Good job.

God bless~
11/01/14
A raging ocean is the perfect setting for a mystery. This dog lover can certainly appreciate your anxiety over your loyal sidekick. Great job!
The storm and sea provided some great mood for this piece. I liked the happy ending.
11/02/14
I too love the melancholy dark mood of this piece. And the confused state of mind made your MC believable and endeared him to the reader. Thanks for sharing your creative work with us!
11/02/14
Your desciptive writing is great in this piece. I could almost feel the wind and stormy weather. I liked the happy ending too.
Powerful imagery! You have a wondrous gift!
Hugs, Judi
1 Timothy 3:16 KJV
You have a really good idea here. It's quite different from all of the other stories I've read this week. I totally appreciate your out-of-the-box thinking. I tend to think differently than most. Sometimes it works and other times, I'm sure I can see people looking at me with one eyebrow raised. Stretching beyond that box, though, is how all great stories begin--taking the author out of his comfort zone.

I noticed a few minor things. You switched your tenses a few times from present to past and back again. For me, writing in the present tense can be quite difficult to do, but if done correctly, quite effective. For me personally, the story of the missing dog might not be suspenseful enough. I like it, but I think you needed more elements of danger. One suggestion would be at the ocean, have the MC sputter and choke on the salt water with racing thoughts like Oh dear, I worried about telling the kids that something had happened to Woolie. But now, they may lose their father too. Oh I hope they understand I came out only because I love them... Then have him black out. Then again, when the tree branch clunked him in the head, it would have added more tension if you had played that out more. If read quickly, it could almost be missed.

I think the ending was quite brilliant. The man set out to rescue dog only to have the dog rescue him. It's a great twist and the message speaks volumes. Often, in life, we set out to be the hero, only to discover we are the ones needing rescuing. I see tons of potential in this piece. Turn the MC into a 12 yo boy and you'd have a thrilling story in my favorite genre. Most important, don't get discouraged. You deserve a Happy Dance for entering. Many people shied away this week. It's not an easy genre to write at all. Every time you enter the challenge, you're a winner in my book. The idea of the challenge isn't to place high (though that's certainly a bonus when it happens), but to improve your writing skills and another bonus is to touch others. By being open to red ink, meeting a tight deadline, writing a story you may never had written if not for the prompt, and learning to write on topic are all valuable skills. You may not see the rewards of your hard work every week, but keep at it and before you know it, you'll keep improving. You've some great talent and a unique way of seeing things. God will do many things (most of which you may never be aware of) through your words. What a blessing to be used by God in that manner. Keep writing my friend!