The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 871 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
This is really good.

You had a way of gradually explaining and revealing the full story as it went along. This is usually very difficult for beginner writers.

Again you did well with the bringing them all together at the end. A nice ending.

Thank you for your writing.
Thanks for this piece filled with messages. I love how it ended with peace in the family.
09/12/14
Well written this sweet read. I thought it was a very good tale.

God bless~
09/15/14
This one caught me by surprise. Your description of a war-zone, coupled with the MC's mother having died from being shot totally had me thinking it was an entirely different type of story than what it turned out to be. It served to really drive the point home strongly that family wars can feel like a literal war.

Your story telling here was exquisite. You let it unfold gradually, paragraph by paragraph and did a lot of showing as opposed to telling, and your MC was compelling, authentic and relatable.

Just an overall great job!
09/16/14
You've done an excellent job of capturing the reader. Strong visuals connecting us with the MC. This piece looks more advanced than a beginner's entry. Great work!

For some constructive critique, try eliminating a few more non essential words. Your opening paragraph is powerful, hooking the reader straight out of the gate. The 3rd sentence of that paragraph... "Tears formed in her eyes but her own will built a dam refusing to let them fall down her cheeks." I felt would be more powerful by taking out, "her own will built". Perhaps, "Reaching deep, she found the will to dam them up, refusing to allow those tears to spill..." But maybe that's just personal taste?

Again, good work. I look forward to your next entry!
09/16/14
"Without moving from the floor, they each began telling funny stories about their mother and for the moment, the sadness lifted. The sound of laughter erupted continuously and blew healing and relief across their hearts like a cool breeze on a hot summer day. Rosie was sure Mama was smiling from the Heavens as her prayers had finally been answered."

My mom died when I was 5-years-old (in 1985)(her photo is on my profile page) and this last paragraph is exactly how it is for me in real life. To remember the funny stories or at least hear others tell them does my heart such good.

I really like this one!
That was excellent. I agree with Joe, I was expecting a totally different story. But you drew a fine parallel between the imagery of a war zone and a family's fights. Wow.

It really drew me in, and kept me reading all the way. I could relate to it because of things that happened in my own family after a death.

That was strongly written. Somehow I don't think you'll be in Level 1 much longer...
If the judges ignore this noble piece, I will have to eat my big toes, which will make it very difficult for me to walk in your example of an extremely well-written story. Sigh. I see you shooting up to Masters level before me. This was filled with inspiring magic . . .
09/18/14
Congratulations!
God bless~
So happy I don't have to eat my big toes!

Great story - God bless you muchly . . .
09/22/14
Hey Congrats! I figured this would do well.
Good job and great descriptions! Loved the name choice on the MC. ;)
Good job and great descriptions! Loved the name choice on the MC. ;)
08/13/16
Your use of words is extraordinary. But I do believe you need to think abut structuring and developing you plot. Paragraph one seemed to be useless. Why not start with paragraph two and then explain the shooting. The rest of the story is powerful.

But the confusion between paragraph one and the real plot of the story is unclear.

Your telling about the shooting and now the lead character is unclear. The reader has to wade through your structuring, especially from paragraph to the next.