The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 615 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
04/14/16
I thought you had some good descriptive elements in your writing. For example: Pointing over to a handsomely chiseled tanned blonde man.

However, some of the dialogue was unnecessary. For example, *How are you doing?" or *Very good. Thanks." This does very little to move the story forward. Also watch out for using too many exclamation points.

I see so much potential. Keep writing.
04/14/16
You created a bit of mystery and your characters were believable. Keeping entering the challenge. I started in level one in 2009. The challenge has helped me a lot.
04/15/16
sweet story = well done
04/15/16
Aww...I really enjoyed this. Sweet and tender story.

Blessings~
04/15/16
I enjoyed the honesty of your voice, the enthusiasm of your pace. I like the characterization and while, like all of us, somethings could be a little smoother, I enjoyed this very much. I thought I should have been reading this in a much higher level. Keep reading good writing and keep writing. You have a natural voice for this. Keep up the good work. Excellent job.
We need chapter two and three but the challenge is just too short.
04/17/16
I liked how you developed your characters. I found this story to be compelling and interesting.
04/18/16
I enjoyed your story line and the pace of the story. My only critique is I felt you were creating some sort of conflict with Carol in accepting Razma, or her relationship with the young man, but it never fully developed for the reader. It left me a little confused when Carol offered to leave the table later. Probably just me,though- I get confused easily these days. All in all, good job.
This is a lovely story. You do a nice job with showing the topic in an interesting way. I enjoyed your characters. Your beginning drew me in and I was eager to see the conflict develop.

I noticed a few things that could make your story even stronger. In the beginning, you could do more showing instead of telling. For example:
As the sweat dripped down Carol's face, she spotted Tianna fanning herself in the shade.
"Can I join you?" Without waiting for an answer, Carol planted herself down. "It's so hot, and you've got the shade!"
Instead of telling it was hot, I tried to show it. I also added a question mark and got rid of the tagine (she said) to tighten it up some.
I noticed some inconsistencies too like Carol hadn't met Razma, but then mentioned she noticed a change in her. Another one was Tianna nudging Carol, but then you said Tianna followed Carol's hint. Even though Carol got up first, in my mind, the nudging was the first hint.
You also have some POV shifts. It's a hard concept to understand, but you showed the thoughts of three different characters. Usually, especially in a piece this size, you have a MC and the reader can only see, hear, or know what the MC sees hears or knows. I struggled with this for quite a while myself. On the forums in Jan's Writing Basics, Jan just did a lesson called head hopping that might help you better understand it.

I know it might feel like I've been overly critical, and I don't want you to feel discouraged because I believe you have a lot of potential. You've done a nice job of developing your characters, especially in such a limited word count. I have a real sense of their personalities. I like the conflict and the territorial feel. It made me eager to keep reading. Your dialog felt realistic for the most part and also moved the story forward.
I also liked the ending. I could feel the passion. I think you tried to pack too much into 750 words. I did that repeatedly at first too. Instead, it would be even stronger if you focused on just one thing like being nervous about Mark. You explain a lot in that last paragraph, but each explanation could make a great story in itself. I can feel your passion for writing and sense God has some huge plans in store for you. You definitely have been bitten by the story bug. I can't wait to read more of your work. Don't get discouraged, but keep writing and reading and commenting on other challenge entries. You will blossom into something more spectacular than you can imagine. I feel this strongly. Good job.
The story is sweet and the characterization is interesting. After this week's Challenge, might I suggest placing it into the Critique Circle if possible? Here, you would get valuable input to know which lessons to pursue. It's an invaluable way to grow as a writer, as we all do!
04/21/16
Although you didn't place this week, I saw great potential in your writing. FaithWriters provides a good opportunity to grow and develop as a writer.