The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 531 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
04/23/15
The best thing about this pleasant entry is the authentic and relatable voice. It's casual and self-deprecating, and that made for an entertaining read, which is what all writers strive for.

Be careful about misplaced modifiers. For example, in your sentence, Growing up dinner time was always an adventure , the words "growing up" modify "dinner time," but it's not "dinner time" that was growing up. A better way to write that would be something like When I was growing up, dinner time was always an adventure.

There were a few additional mechanical errors: A slip into present tense in the first sentence of the sixth paragraph, for example, and several places where commas are needed. And I don't think that your address to Audrey at the end of the piece is particularly effective; it's as if you suddenly turn your back on your reader to engage in this personal conversation.

If you were to publish this, I'd recommend a final polish to tweak these minor flaws. However, as a whole, this is a strong piece of writing. You made your point with humor and without preachiness.
04/23/15
I loved this! Thanks for sharing this heartfelt piece with us...it touched me as I'm sure it will others.

God bless~
04/24/15
THis was a well-written story. I could easily identify with your plight. My mom was an excellent cook but she would over indulge in the onions for my taste. She would often say "you can't taste them." I would reply, then why put them in" Your style of writing was very creative and flowed easily.
I liked this. I think you have a delightful, yet subtle, sense of humor. You did a great job with the dialog.

I'd urge you to find a good proofreader to help you catch little things like the opening lines of the first two paragraphs were incomplete sentences. You also missed quite a few commas that would make it easier to read. This is just my opinion, but I wonder if the beginning would have been more of a grabber if you had started with a conflict. For example, you could do something like this: When I was ten, I decided to take a stand by refusing to take I couldn't fathom eating another bite of my Mom's meatloaf.
I'm sorry, I was trying to fix my example when my fat finger touched submit instead of the line above (which shows that everyone, even a critiquer needs to tweak things until they feel right :)) For example: When I was ten, I decided to take a stand by refusing to take another bite of my mom's meatloaf. Then you could do a quick review of the beginning and how the evening progressed.

You really did a great job of this. I could easily picture this unfolding at the dinner. It was as good as watching a sitcom. You have a real knack for storytelling. The ending is often the hardest part, but you nailed that too. It left me with a smile and a warm feeling. Great job.
04/30/15
This brought back cheerful memories, of sitting at the table with my family. As a child I was a picky eater, and got grounded on several occasions for not eating certain foods. You did a great job. Keep writing.
Congratulations on ranking 6th in your level. The highest rankings can be found on the message boards.
http://www.faithwriters.com/Boards/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=39298