The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 354 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
02/02/23
That was a very interesting story! Did the calf survive?

I'm not sure you focused on the topic word, though I saw it a couple of times.

I did the same thing with the first of these challenges. It's not enough to use the word, the story must wrap around it. I know better now.

But you tried and entered. Good for you!
Good story. Lots of imagery: mud suction grabbing our boots. You included information for those who don't raise cows. I really don't have much to complain about the writing, other than I had to assume the hired hand was calling.
I can see the use of "here" being the muddy hillside, but I have trouble finding the "hear". I also see very little ties to Christian beliefs. The last sentence seems to be tacked on.
Overall a good job. Keep writing.

02/08/23
Loved the imagery. However, I feel let down that I don’t know the outcome.
As someone who grew up across from a farm, you did a great job of describing the mess cows can make in the mud. You don't have to have a Christian message, just suitable for a Christian audience (BTW). And you do show that the calf is in God's hands at the end. I'm usually okay with open endings, but this didn't feel as authentic to me since each cow and calf is so important to the farm, it seems odd to me that the MC just left the calf. Even if you had MC wait til later when more help was available, it might have felt more authentic to me. I do like the message of sometimes we do just have to leave it to God and that can be hard to do, though. You did mention both topic words in this interesting story.
Also, I want to point out it's quite clear Rich, the hired hand was calling. You don't have to have a tag line each time there is dialog. Personally I prefer descriptive lines over tag lines.
Congratulations!
Congratulations on your EC. Happy Dance!