The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 219 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
What a gripping story.
Thank you
07/16/24
You've captured how our personal God communicates with our pleas very well. The writing is clear, taking us into the narrator's internal struggle. My only recommendation is to introduce the narrator's relationship to Jemima earlier and let it develop a bit more.
08/03/24
Since you posted this story in refence to the contest, I looked up on your profile to see which theme it was written for.

Seeing the theme was hunger, I'd say probably your first "error" if you want to call it that, was that your story seemed to be about need in general, rather than physical hunger. I also competed in that theme with "Masada" which focused on spiritual hunger, and did not place very well. If you read the winning entries, the judges were looking for literal, physical hunger, not anything else. Personally, I like the focus on spiritual hunger, as that is eternal, but they clearly did not count that as on topic.

Also, it seemed to me that your title about "the decision" was only partially concluded in the ending. It seemed like the ending kind of crashed to a sunder close. Were you out of word allowance? 750 does not give much room to flesh stuff out.

I also compared you story to the winning story. One thing the judges do NOT seem to like, (and readers in a hurry, too) is stories that look heavy on the page. Yours really wasn't bad, but it was not as light in appearance as the story that won your category. I'm not exactly sure how to explain what I mean, but big paragraphs look heavy on the page. Even if you keep that action moving, it still seems more daunting to read. Not sure if that made any sense whatsoever.

Predictability is another big one. It seemed pretty obvious once I figured out that the question was if she would stay or not, that she was going to stay. Apparently, they don't like that. Suspense. What is going to happen? I can't put it down until I know. etc. In this fast paced world, you have to really catch the readers attention with an irresistible hook.

Have you ever tried fishing? When a fish bites the hook, you have to jerk the line to make sure the fish is stuck. If you are sleeping on the job, the fish may be able to get away once it realizes it bit the wrong thing. You get the reader to bite you story with a good title, but then you have to set the hook with suspense and a really good story. Then you have to real them in and keep them on the line with a great story from beginning to end.

Obviously, we can't predict the judges very well at all. Sometimes I think one of them is in a bad mood and really cranky when they read the article. I don't know. You could also try ordering a rating report if you are upgraded far enough. Those don't always make sense either, but it tells you where you rated well and where you crashed score wise.

Anyway, I'm not an expert here, but that is just a few things that stuck out to me. For the most part, I'd say it was a pretty good story, but we still have to keep improving to make it in the writing world. Keep writing!
08/03/24
oops. Sorry, that was supposed to go in the critique section, not here.