The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 863 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
03/21/05
Very well-done, I enjoyed this. My only criticism is that I didn't care much for the way it ended - it needed the same punch the rest of the story had.
03/21/05
Very well done, and very creative! It really held my interest.
"The night was as still as death" was a great opening line. It set the mood for the majority of the piece. You managed to capture the dark mood of those young soldiers during a difficult time in our country's history. I especially like to hear about our strong, powerful leaders that give in to true emotions. You did a fine job.
03/26/05
What a great storyteller you are. This piece held my interest throughout and I was pleased to see your fears replaced by your witnessing the prayers of the General.
Excellent bit of writing here; the thoughts of the young soldier and the cry of the leader who, as all good leaders, doesn't want to see the death of his men. I liked the ending. It allowed me to gradually fade away with the soldier; it wasn't about the battle or the cause it was about the human quality and the ending let me fade with him.
03/28/05
After reading this I know why you are in the Advanced group. You are very talented. Your words paint a picture complete with emotions and humanity. Also you feature the leader's greatest quality being his petition for protection on his men. A leader must know he also has a leader who rules in the affairs of men. Thank you for giving us a moment in time that came aline in your writing.
Your story really touched my heart. You did paint a picture with your "vivid" words. My heart was aching for him to have peace and you so beautifully let him have a "positive" encounter with a LEADER who was having and encounter with HIS LEADER. I loved how you resolved his torment with peace. And the line that tickled my funny bone was 'praying with a fervency that I hadn't seen since Old Zeke the deacon.' That painted a picture in my mind.... Beautiful story!