The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 1039 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
04/13/06

Thanks for sharing your story with us! I liked your basis a lot. Your character was good and dialog flowed really nicely! I did feel a little rushed, it felt to easy for me when she prayed... Maybe have her struggle with herself, "do I really want to start *that* again?" kinda thing. I just wondered if the person you made her out to be would give in that fast? And that's just my opinion. Great job!
04/13/06
I'm not sure I understood "what she needed to do." I had thought it was a spiritual revelation, but it seems as if she "needed" to go back and answer her machine? Or go on this date? I know what you were going for, but it was a bit unclear.

On the positive side, you've created a realistic character, and you've made your readers care about her and her life. Love the optimistic ending!
04/13/06
Interesting story, strong start, but halfway through it seemed to change direction. Felt like two stories squeezed inot one. Like the ending
I agree with the other comments so far. I do like the character as she shows that it is so easy for people to find, or attempt to find, fulfillment in material objects. Good job!
04/14/06
Loved your insight on the emptiness of acquiring "things". You sprinkled your story with meaningful words such as "empty" and "no room in her life". The character kept referring to her "empty" home. In truth, at that moment it was not yet a home, rather it was an empty house. Your story points out the difference between working for that which is empty, vain, and the dissatifaction that it leaves vs the living by the priorities that are eternal. I agree with the others about her sudden change of heart after a memory and a brief prayer prompted by the sight of a cross.But we write with a limit to the number of words we can use and perhaps that explains why you used that approach.
04/15/06
A disappointing end...never know what happens. I feel cheated somehow. Nice story, well written...but left this reader feeling empty - with no fulfillment.