The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 632 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
04/15/16
This was a powerful and somber story with a prolific message.

Well done.

Blessings~
I thought it was a well put together story except for one bit in the first paragraph. I couldn't put the female high school student in the medium security male prison. (I don't know if this could really take place.)
04/15/16
I also was surprised a girl would be allowed in the prison, and also that they would allow an interview of more than 2 hrs. However, it was an excellent message.
04/15/16
Tom's story could be commonplace. You do a good job of making him a real person. It's so easy to dismiss criminals as some faceless different kind of being. You have humanized criminals more generally than just Tom by making him a real person. But except for reassuring him that pain is not silly, the MC doesn't engage with him at all. You tell at the end that the interview transformed her, but you neglect to show it through her interaction with him.
04/18/16
I thought you showed a real gift for description. I especially liked the line: Anger is a self built fire starter, and I became a wick waiting to be lit and ultimately burned.

Red Ink:

A teenage girl wouldn't be let in the men's prison. Even if she was allowed to visit, it would be on video or behind glass.

One of your sentences changed tenses, so I rewrote it like this: My married father lived across town and devoted most of his time to his other family.

Each dialogue by a different character needs to be its own paragraph.

The narrative by the main characters is more telling then showing.

Keep writing!



I really enjoyed your take on the topic. I found it fresh and interesting. There's nothing as humbling as going into a prison.

My main red ink is you have quite a few passive lines. I think you'd be surprised if you counted them. One way (although not always true) to spot passive lines is to count how many times you use a form of the verb to be (was, were, is). Your opening line is passive. (If I wanted to change my prior line from passive to active, I could've done this:You wrote your opening line as a passive one.) Try to start with something that will pull the reader in immediately. For example: Licking my dry lips, my heartbeat echoed in my ears. What on earth am I doing going into a prison? I thought field trips were supposed to be fun. I suppressed a nervous giggle when I heard the clanging of the steel doors locking me inside. Crossing my legs, I glanced around for the nearest bathroom.
I added some body language and internal dialog to create both conflict and a picture for the reader.

I liked your dialog. (Remember to start a new paragraph each time someone different speaks.) It really helped to develop your characters. I think the social ladder in prison is quite intriguing. I liked the way you approached it. You held my attention right to the end. Nicely done.
I want to stress that comments (including mine) are just opinions. You might not agree with them all. I visited prisons as a teen several times. The laws may vary prison to prison. I also did think you showed how Tom impacted the MC. The shuddering and staring speechlessly showed it to me. It's interesting how different people can read the same stories, yet take different things away. No one is right or wrong, just sharing their thoughts and opinions. I often think that shows the Holy Spirit using your words in many different ways. God is so powerful. He can use your story to help someone in ways you can never imagine, and that's pretty awesome!
04/21/16
Congratulations, Dot, on placing 2nd place in the Intermediate category. I just knew this piece would place in the top five.

I enjoy reading your pieces. You continue to grow as a writer.
04/21/16
Congrats!

Blessings~