The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 957 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
09/09/06
Quite an experience. Yes, at some time everyone and everything needs to be re-channelled. Good writing.
09/10/06
This is so rich, I have had to read it two, three or more times. The writing lures the reader to come join the exotic experience of the narrator.

But, oh! that first paragraph! Those long sentences distracted me, trying to find which verb goes with what subject! So, the reader could miss the whole point. [I know, I have the same problem, needing to cut my own too-long sentences.] While the writer knows what he wants to say, the reader needs that help to sort out the message.

Still, I would say that this is an exceptional writer, worth watching :)
Richly descriptive and a well captured moment. The heart is as observant as the eye too - noting how people think with their pain - and the reader is left with as much to dwell on as the writer. There was a slight change of tense in the opening paragraph which threw me a little, and perhaps a little polish needed mid-way - but this was excellent and I liked it very much. God bless. xx
I LOVE your style, your literary, almost nonchalant construction of sentences which always threaten to go on too long and sometimes do, the second sentence being a good example. But I still loved it, even though I haven’t the faintest idea what this means: ‘After centuries of choke-chain connected gold-leafed towers …’ Who cares what it means when it is such a fabulous string of words. Have you read Manley Hopkins? You must have, with your predilection for hyphenated words, which create a different kind of rhythm from normal English. I just have enough breath in this old body to say the whole sentence, gasping through the ‘faded blue stripe’ and the marvellous ‘rain-stained river walls’, lingering over the wonderfully evocative ‘nostalgic decadence’ (tantalisingly near-tautologous but not quite)from which I, never mind Seville, was only beginning to recover before we are regaled with an even LONGER sentence, which again I hardly understood – which old man? Picasso perhaps? Why is it a kidnapped city? What are tocadores? I’m afraid I was a French major and all things Spanish have passed me by. But again, who cares? I (and obviously the judges too) relished these sentences because I loved the rhythm and the exotic vocab which painted such a vivid picture. I think you may have lost marks through not keying the article into the theme of River more deeply. The river seems to be just the means of getting you to a party – until you tie the story up with a mystical reference to the river needing to be re-channeled one day, and the girl, and all of us. Again, I’m not sure what you mean but I enjoy half-understood stuff (it happens to me a lot!) because it leaves scope for my imagination.

A minor point is that hashish and vodka don’t need capitalizing.
I don’t think you mean ‘benignly’ which means harmlessly, with no ill intent, like a benign tumour. I think you meant ‘without objecting’. Anyway we’re told to ditch adverbs and ‘accepted’ says it all.

La anarquia is TWO words, but I know what you mean!

‘I was fascinated’ spoils the paragraph, telling us what you’ve already shown us clearly.

‘particularly me …………… …. looked particularly ……..’

I know that in 30 years Spanish will be the first language of the USA, but maybe it’s a bit soon to write bi-lingual texts for the general public? I’m a linguist so I managed the second and third questions, but why did they ask him ‘How are your llamas?’ I think maybe just have the ONE ‘standard question’ (about Bush) and that could be in Spanish because you do explain what it said. But the other two are superfluous to the story, even though the truth, I’m sure.

I wanted to hear how the girl explained anarchism! On the other hand I was high on the thick hashishan smoke by then so I wouldn’t have paid attention. I would be very surprised if this is an invented article. It has all the hallmarks of a biographical account. It drifts through the events in just the way that memory does when recalling an evening, and also it swings between generalized happenings and descriptions, and tiny, detailed observations. It’s a section out of a chapter of a book of Memoires of My Year in Spain – and as such, hugely enjoyable. Years back I had evenings exactly like that – I remember one such occasion when we visited friends in Hait Ashbury in 71 …

Thanks for that, Peter! (And how ARE your llamas anyhow?)
09/20/06
Geoff meet Peter; Peter meet Geoff. I think you two are going to be a hoot to watch! You both seem to exist in that rarified atmosphere of linguistic Shangri-La delights many of the rest of us can only enjoy through your eyes. Your readers won't be able to help loving you both, I would imagine!