The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 454 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
02/05/16
Iloved this well written entry. Being born and raised in New York, I traveled those trains working in Manhattan for a good portion of my life. It brought back memories of my younger days, I always preferred the first car as well!

Great job and excellent story.

God bless~
02/05/16
I think you need to rethink the beginning. The bumpy ride and the next sentence left me perplexed, rather than piqueing my curiosity. Also a couple of punctuation errors. I still enjoyed the story.
I liked how you introduced your story with the subway ride. It fit into the meaning of your thoughts well.

Yes, He is the way.

Nicely written. This should be an encouragement to any thinking of "getting off the subway" before reaching our destination.

Keep writing as you are directed by the Holy Spirit.
This is a lovely devotion. I've never been on the NY subways and only rode Chicago's elevated train/subway one weekend, and it terrified me. I'm a country girl at heart, yet I could still relate to your great message and even envision riding the trains (I think my heart rate went up, but that's because you put me right there with you.)

My red ink would involve your beginning and ending. Granted they are probably two of the most important yet difficult judging criteria. First remember to put quotation marks around Bible verses as they are direct quotes. Your opening line was a passive one. With a bit of rearranging and tightening, you could turn it into something like this:
Riding the NY subways when I was a fourteen-year-old girl taught me a valuable lesson. As I bumped about, I'd look out the window and shiver when I saw only darkness encompassing the train. Periodically, a light would shine, giving me a glimpse of my location. Even today, I can close my eyes, crinkle my nose, and remember the subway scents--a mixture of sweat, stale fast food, lingering cigarette smoke, and the metallic, sulphuric smell of the wheels rubbing against the tracks.
Okay, I took some liberties, especially with the smells. Since I've never been on the subway, I can only imagine the smells, but I bet you could describe them way better than that. I tried to do more showing by using body language and active sentences.

As for your ending, you don't need that last line. You already did a great job of stating your message so you don't need to repeat it. The reader will already be asking herself that question because of your great way of building the story without being preachy.

I really like devotions that start with real stories that the reader can relate to. You did a nice job of picking a good Bible verse to build your message on. I like your take on the topic too. If you haven't already submitted something to FW daily devotions, I'd urge you to do so. I think you have a gift for writing devotions. I thoroughly enjoyed this one.