The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 1305 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
05/18/06
Interesting ... but I wonder where the other family members were (if any) who could have talked to Christopher. Also instead of saying "Kate was taken aback; she was curious why he wanted to know. “Why do you want to know?” she asked her son curiously." ... perhaps change ..."why do you want to know?" she asked her son curiously."... watch reptition of word such as familiar. Story leaves me with many questions, but has an interesting concept.
You know, this little piece has merit. The story is a painful account of loss, and I enjoyed reading it. But... something just kept gnawing at me the whole time.....What if you wrote this story in the first person? Maybe the child's or the mother's point of view. I bet you it would just spring out at you then. Your writing has potential. Try to make your characters come alive. Breath life into them. You can do it! Push yourself because God has blessed you with a wonderful writing gift!
05/19/06
I like the fact that you are in beginner's and are using dialog and creating a story. :) Good job bringing heartfelt feelings between the mom and child. Take the suggestions of the others, plus choose stronger grammer and tighter dialog. You do have potential. Reading from the winner's list will help you gain some more knowledge. Keep submitting!
05/20/06
You spun a moving story here. Watch your punctuation (you should start a new paragraph for each speaker, for example), which will help tighten it up a little. I, too have unanswered questions, but enjoyed the read a lot. THank you.
05/22/06
There's definitely a lot of potential here. My biggest issue was with Christopher's use of the word "prosperous," which seemed not consistent with his apparent age. A sweet story, though, and told in a very tender manner.
I agree with all the previous comments, however, the use of the word "properous" was explained in the writing. The nurse had initially used "prosperous" and the boy repeated incorrectly, as any child his age would. Good story.
05/23/06
A very sweet little story! The emotions came across very well.

Watch your point of view - you switched back and forth. The story would be much tighter if the POV was consistent. (Feel free to PM me if you want specific examples or clarification.)

Keep writing and honing! You're headed in the right direction!!!