The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 607 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
06/17/16
You painted a good picture of the Sarahs of the world. You had more words available so I would have liked to see it expanded further.
You have created a complex character in Sarah, and effectively engage the reader to want to know more about her and her scars.

I have taken the liberty of tweaking the first two paragraphs, just to present some alternate ways you might have consolidated information and descriptions. I left the last sentence in the first paragraph off, because I felt that you had already covered her aversion to her scar.

Sarah glanced at the clock on the vanity, staring at her reflection in the steamy bathroom mirror, mascara wand in hand. Late for work again, and it was only Tuesday. Hurriedly, she wiped off a spot with her hand and peered closer. Frowning, she carefully combed her crimson bangs over the jagged two-inch scar on her forehead, a haunting reminder of a past incident, before applying the second coat of Maybelline.

Sarah quickly finished dressing, fished her designer bag from amongst the rumpled covers on her bed and sprinted to the kitchen to grab her lunch and keys, as she raced out the door.
She dreaded the long, early morning drive to her workplace almost as much as she dreaded waking up each morning to face another day. Taking the job an hour away from her home in Orlando had seemed like a good idea a year ago. The pay was good and she liked being one of the only mental health clinicians in the quaint and historic town of Mt. Dora. But perhaps it was time to update her resume, again.

And this is just another concept of what the ending might have looked like with more showing than telling.

Sarah removed her compact from her bag, opened it, and set it on the desk in front of her. She eased the bangs to either side, imagining "compassion" filling the pale streak in beautiful calligraphy. She reached back in to the bag for two small barrettes.

Remember, this is just one person's opinion. I do not go in to this much detail unless I already see good work. You have many excellent, evocative word choices, and draw the reader to care about your MC. I look forward to reading more of your writing.
This is a nice story. I felt the MC's pain. I don't like my body and I have horrible scars that no one can see. I could really relate to her.

My main red ink would be you started with a passive line. Using an active one will help paint a picture for the reader. For example: Groaning, Sarah looked into the mirror. Tears spilled over, smearing her mascara. I'm late for work, yet, I'm obsessing over the way I look. How am I ever going to succeed at helping others if I'm hung up on this stupid scar? She threw the mascara tube into the sink, grabbed her sweater, and scurried to her car.

This is a really fast example of how using active lines, internal dialog (they are in italics instead of quotation marks by using this code without spaces: < i > at the beginning and < /i > at the end of the part to be italicized), and body language can paint a picture for the reader. It's not perfect, but I hope it helps show you what I mean.

You have a nice message here. I'm sure many can relate to not feeling content with life, yet not quite knowing why. I also liked the scar equation. Jesus came as a human so he would know what it feels like. He truly understands everything that troubles us from what may seem insignificant to the huge things. If it's important to us, it's important to him. Nice job and good message.
06/17/16
You have profiled some deep inner questions in very clear ways.
Though you are well within the word limit - with over 200 left to you - I feel you have cramped your details of MC's revelation and the healing she gained. To fill out this part of your story would draw your readers along with you.
But overall, very good work.
06/19/16
Sarah is a character with much turmoil within. I think you could use the rest of the words to expound on why she hates the scar so much.

The last line in the first paragraph is unnecessary. Holly had some good insight on how to rewrite it.

I think you show a real gift of building strong characters, and I hope you continue to write.
06/22/16
You presented a complex and emotional piece for the topic and did a fine job with it.

Good message too!

Blessings
06/23/16
Congrats!

Blessings~
06/23/16
Congratulations, GiGi, on your 3rd place win in the Beginners category this week.

I think you have a great chance of moving up if you learn to develop your story. What has helped me is to read other peoples work each week, especially the Editors Choice winners.
06/25/16
Congratulations on 3rd Place.
WEll Done GiGi. A very good read.