The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 847 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
09/13/05
That is sooo a Jesus thing to do! ;) Nice and true to form. Thanks and God bless.
09/13/05
A few picky details: "She and Harry" rather than "Her and Harry", and put spaces between your paragraphs. That said, your story was very sweet, and I really was able to feel Phoebe's loneliness. Thanks for writing.
09/15/05
Harry, George, Mrs. Ellis, Phoebe, Julie...I got a little bogged down with all the names. When you use names, the reader has to keep track of all of them in her head. It isn't really important to know the names of the husbands, or even the co-worker. You could just refer to them as husbands who died, or as co-worker. Also, paragraphs needed!
09/21/05
Sharon, this was a really nice little story, that got a bit lost in the translation. Probably the main problem was that the dialogue was all clumped together. With speech, you need to start a new paragraph every time the person speaking changes.

Also, you need to watch out for dropped "ed." You aren't alone with this - quite a few new writers accidentally leave "ed" off some of their words, for example, "Mrs. Ellis stepped out of her office and ask Phoebe.." That "ask" should have been "asked."

It would probably be worth submitting this to the Critique Circle to get some constructive editing suggestions. It can be a great way to help point new writers in the right direction.

Don't be discouraged though Sharon. I really thought the idea behind this was good. Now you just need to discover how to polish it so that it really shines. With love, Deb (Challenge Coordinator)