The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 676 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
06/10/10
I'm glad your MC did the right thing in the end, and the scripture reference was good. I did get a little confused over some of the characters (is Brock Ponyboy or are they just talking about him?) Also, putting space between your paragraphs will help make your story more readable. Hope you'll keep writing!
06/12/10
Interesting plot. It will help the reader to leave an extra line between paragraphs. I had to learn that too when I first came to FW. Good use of dialogue.
It's a great story but it did take some work to keep me focused. There were a lot of characters and I had trouble following the pace.

But once I slowed down i really enjoyed it. I think you were limited by the word count. I could see this being a chapter of a tween book.

Keep up the good work, you have the start of a potentially wonderful book.
Not a bad story, and the dialogue was quite good.
The first paragraph could be improved with some punctuation, and, as others have said, leave a space between your paragraphs.
Lots of potential here, well done.

06/14/10
As has been said, there was a bit too much information overload here. Better to have reduced the characters and used the extra space to describe the setting. What was that bookstore like? Was it warm, friendly, untidy etc?
Nevertheless you had a good moral and I particularly liked the way you wrote of an angel and a demon on the MC's shoulders. Nice metaphorical way of conveying the moral uncertainties
I liked your story very much. You provided a good resolution to the mc's problem. Ponyboy was a great character in the book, but you might have left him out here to reduce the number of characters and avoid confusion for those who hadn't read THE OUTSIDERS.
I agree with one of the above comments. I think you have the making of a good tween book. Your writing style fits, and there's enough content to be an interesting read, what with the death of the mother, the rebellion, the friends, and the Christian alternative. There is a sad want of Christian novels geared toward teenagers.
06/16/10
I LOVE The Outsiders as well. I liked the set up -but perhaps the story was too much for the word count. Would love to see a second, longer draft of this with some more atmosphere.