The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 723 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
Oooh. hmmm. Spec-fic? I think it is...though I could be wrong. Am I? I like this, the atmosphere is very well done here and I'm curious to know how the story continues!
05/30/09
Well-written and atmospheric...and leaves me with lots of questions. What's with the burned hand, and the hundred years?

You had more words, so just a few more sentences would have been great--it's fine to be mysterious, and you did it very well, but just a tad more would leave your readers less puzzled.

Very good writing skills.
06/01/09
This story pulled me in and held my interest until the last paragraph. Then I was confused and felt a bit cheated. I'm not sure I followed what the ending was all about.
06/03/09
I agree with the other reviewers. I liked the story but got confused with the last paragrasph, why the burned hand ?, why having to push beyond the limits of human endurance to reach safty? I read the whole thing again to try and see if I had missed a storm a lightening strike. ditch the last paragraph and I think the story is complete!
Now that the all clear for brick throwing has come about, I think I can safely post this:

I thought I made the story clear enough within the hints, because I dislike just coming out and telling people things.

What has thrown.. so far it seems every reader off is the fact that Kyle is not human. He's a vampire. I wrote this on the thought of 'if vampires were real, would they be beyond redemption?'

Why did I never come out and say it? Kyle knows what he is, and Jacob knew.. so there was no reason for Kyle to go "I'm a vampire!"
06/03/09
I caught the "undead" aspect by the end, but then again, I know the kinds of twists you like to spin.
06/03/09
I got that the MC was a vampire. This was very interesting, and I would love to read more about Kyle. Thank you for sharing!
06/03/09
Very good. I liked this. Want the book...or movie. My only question is, is it a zombie or vampire? A different look at the "undead" than anyone else has taken that I know of. Excellent!
06/03/09
Interesting with a melancholy feel. Some seem to think the ending's not there - maybe it is just a copy and paste error? Or, just a mystery we thickies should have been able to solve.

Thanks. Colin
06/03/09
First, I like your style and creativity.

I'm in agreement with the idea that redemption is available for anyone, no matter what, and I realize that this is a piece of fiction. If I'm reading it correctly, you're saying that a vampire has become a Christian. I'd suggest taking great care with mixing the secular (or even profane) with the concepts of Christianity.

As general comments, you've left out the word of (friendship instead of damnation...), and sometimes ending a sentence instead of continuing after a comma would be a better idea. Try it out in the future.
06/03/09
I read the story before reading the comments. I was so excited because the last paragraph led to me realize he was a vampire. Rats! That point is already revealed. I'm not here to consider whether this is scripturally possible or not, I'm just here to say this was a creative, unique take on this week's topic. Your story has caused a stir and deeper discussion of your story, which is a compliment to the author. Well done!
06/04/09
I guessed vampire as well. It's a nice commentary that even a vampire can realize what a precious gift Christ offers. I gues it's true the vampire can never receive the gift, but he clearly knows the value. . . too bad there are so many non-vampires that don't.
This is great! I love the vampy twist at the end - totally not what I expected. Well written and emotion-packed. You have a few comma breaks that should be periods, but other than that small thing, this is excellent work.
Another comment after reading the other comments. Um, yah, It's VERY obvious that the MC is a vampire. If you ditched the last paragraph as some suggested, the whole point of the story (and the revealing of what he is) would be lost. KUDOS from this reader! :)
Cat
I'm not normal-something is missing in my head. My first thought about the burned hand was that this was the future and the ozone layer was depleted, that people had to stay inside during the day. Knowing the real scoop now, I STILL like the story. lol
06/04/09
Knowing it was your story, I guessed a nosferatu pretty early on. You certainly do like to push the boundaries, don't you?
My suggestion would be that while you tackle some of the ethical issues reasonably well, you need to develop the mood better, including adding a lot more hints about the true identity of your character. For example, you could include his age earlier in the piece. A clever atmospheric play would be to refer to the moonlight and the fact that he doesn't cast a shadow. One other idea would be with regards to his relationship with the church sanctuary. Traditionally this would have been taboo for a vampire yet you have him retreating into the church right at the end - presumably a sign of his conversion? I think that this is a contrast that you could have built up earlier in the story.
So there you go. I'm glad you're getting so many comments. Hope this was helpful. Gregory