The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 751 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
05/17/08
Wow, this is really good. I felt empathy for the MC and her mother-in-law. You paint very vivid word pictures and the dialogue is totally natural. Good entry!
05/17/08
Your use of sensory details to generate memories is so vivid--quite excellent with a natural rhythm. The last paragraph broke that flow for me, however. I wasn't prepared for her to pledge her support to her husband, particularly the leap from timidly asking if he noticed a problem to telling him he had to deal with it. Nonetheless, I was expecting some kind of self-awareness being reflected in her dialogue/thinking and you certainly provided that. You did a great job of showing the conflict in Jenna's mind as she both notices unsettling details causing her worry and remembers unsettling events causing her pain--without having to state the actual conflict.
05/21/08
This is a cleverly written article and seems more than a notch above the Beginners group. You are so vivid with your word pictures that one can empathize with Jenna and the comparisons that come through with the earlier Edna and the present one help establish how painful these memories are for Jenna.
05/21/08
Very well written. The conversations and flashbacks happen smoothly. Maybe a bit more description on her decision/change of heart to help her mother-in-law. That seemed awkward. Otherwise, it was very enjoyable and an easy read!