The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 932 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
02/08/07
Great object lesson here, and well-realized characters.

You might want to experiment with ways to eliminate some of your dialog tags, to take your (already very good) writing to the next level.

I like the bit about the scar being a reminder. Very good.
02/09/07
Good lesson - I never would have thought of those things. Fun to read.
Very good message. I, too, agree that the dialogue tags are not really neccessary. They distract a little bit from your otherwise well-written story. Love that you have a wise grandfather teaching his grandson through something tangible; the scar. Nicely done.
I really liked this story. It felt a bit like a prelude to the one I wrote, about a grandson remembering the stuff he learnt whilst fishing with his Pop. Thanks for the lesson as well. It was a good parable.
This was a unique take on "fishing," with a beautiful biblical application. You are a gifted writer. Blessings, Cheri
02/14/07
You've done very well bringing forth a few important truths. I would have loved to have seen this a little longer - elaborating on it's depths. Good job and keep writing! Blessings, Jo
02/14/07
Good story, great message. I felt the intro was a lil confusing, a few less words or a comma might have helped. But, overall a strong entry with great potential. God bless.
This was pretty good, I noticed a few places that could be improved, but otherwise the message was well delivered. For dialouge variety, read your piece aloud and see if it sounds like something someone would actually say!
02/14/07
Everyone already gave the suggestions I would have (dialogue tags) but other than that - your message was great, you did well with description and your sentences had variety. Just work on the ideas everyone gave and you will see an enormous increase in the quality and level of your writing since it is already really good! I did the same thing if you look back at some of my earlier ones and learned that lesson from the people here:)
I agree with most of the above comments. You do have a talent. My one suggestion is that Billy's language seems a bit older than I was expecting. For instance instead of him saying "Wow, how intersting." Just have him say, "Wow." But that's just my take on this well-written piece.
02/14/07
I loved the message about the "devil's deceiving bait". Like the previous comment, I was a little confused by little Billy's dialogue. Some of his words and phrases didn't seem to fit a "little" boy.