The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 833 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
10/17/08
Very creative! I like the idea of the "New Great Depression" but why do they have to wear skirts?

The POV didn't seem totally clear - it took me a long time to figure out that Rachel is the mom. Maybe have Rachel look over at her children in the first sentence or two. I also noticed a "your" instead of "you're". It would be helpful to detail why they can't have a Christmas tree, and make the tree a gift rather than the kitty. :)

Other than those tiny details, your writing is enchanting and you did an excellent job painting the scene. Nice work!
10/18/08
Sweet family going through hard times--I liked these people.

This did leave me with some questions about the setting, and I also wasn't sure how a snowfall could go from one snowflake to covering their ankles, and stop and start again, in only 6 blocks.

So glad they took in the kitty!

Excellent planning the way you tied in the lone tree to the events taking place with these family members. Great job with your characterizations. :)
I enjoyed this very sweet family story, and how they counted their blessings, not troubles.