We at FaithWriters are immensely privileged and blessed to get some first-hand insight from multi-published, bestselling Christian author Philip Yancey.
Read on to learn about Mr. Yancey’s writing process, his advice for new writers, and more.
JOANNE SHER: Where do you get ideas for your books and articles?
PHILIP YANCEY: Most start with a question that I have, one to which I don’t know the answer. If I knew the answer, of course, I’d be bored within a few weeks. As a result, many of my books have titles that pose a question (What Good Is God?, Prayer: Does It Make Any Difference?). And often I’ll hear from readers who point out something I’d never thought of or suggest another line of inquiry—that comment will spark my interest and soon I’ll be off on another project. Reading also enters in. I’ll find myself reading in a certain field and then thinking, “I should write about that…”
JOANNE: How did you get your first book published?
YANCEY: I had the advantage of working for a magazine, Campus Life, and as a result I knew some of the people involved in book publishing. I had written hundreds of articles, yet the idea of writing a whole book was intimidating. My very first book, long out of print, was called After the Wedding and told the stories of twelve couples and the problems they faced in the first five years of marriage. I approached it as a collection of articles, unable to carry around the burden of anything longer than an article. The next book, Where Is God When It Hurts, came out of my interviews with people who felt confused by fellow Christians’ mixed advice on the issue of suffering. Getting that first book published is a huge hurdle; surmount that and you’re on your way.
JOANNE: How do you improve your writing?
YANCEY: Two ways: 1) I read voraciously, and try to read writers who have something to teach me about style as well as content. 2) I have a few, very few, trusted friends who will edit me with a scowl. Most people want you to feel good so they give you compliments about your writing, and these don’t help at all (except emotionally). Really, you need some grouches to edit your work.
JOANNE: What advice do you have for new writers?
YANCEY: I always recommend that writers join a writers’ group in which they read aloud their works in progress. Writing is a demanding, stress-producing activity, and is best not attempted alone. Also, I don’t recommend that a writer start out as a freelancer; it’s just too bruising to the psyche. If you can get a job, any job, in a publishing environment, that helps ease the transition to the writing world. And the most important advice: keep writing on a regular basis. Blogs are a new and helpful way to keep the process going. You can’t make money as a blogger, but you keep working with words, which is the essence of writing.
JOANNE: What are some things writers should avoid when seeking publication and/or improvement of their writing?
YANCEY: When I started out I had a fear of running out of material. I kept wanting to hold back stories and ideas for future books. That’s a terrible mistake, I decided. You should pour everything you have into a book if it relates to the topic at all. Don’t worry, more material will appear. Don’t hold back.
JOANNE: How do you handle writer’s block?
YANCEY: I move on to a different part of the writing process. For me, writing divides into three stages: 1) preparation, which includes research and interviews, 2) composing, the source of all the fear and pain, and 3) editing or cleaning up what I’ve written. Writer’s block only hits me in stage number 2, and then I go back and do more research or start editing what I’ve just written until I feel back in the flow again.
JOANNE: Is there anything in your writing journey you wish you had done differently?
YANCEY: I’ve never been asked that! Nothing comes to mind, and for that I feel blessed. My years as a magazine editor were thrilling and gave me great practice. My books with Dr. Brand allowed me to lean on someone else for basic content while I developed my own style. Finally, I turned to more introspective, personal-journey accounts as I focused more on my own story rather than other people’s. Perhaps I wasted some time in the early days of journalism when everything seemed of interest and I wrote about irrelevant topics. Yet overall I have no regrets. The battle I fight now is the pull of distractions: I accept too many speaking engagements, spend time on blogs and Facebook, travel too much. Down deep, these are probably ways of avoiding writing, and I’ll regret that someday.
JOANNE: What does your writing process look like?
YANCEY: I begin by reading everything I can on a subject—within limits, of course. When I wrote about Jesus and about prayer, it was impossible to read the many shelves of books. Usually I interview ordinary people, dozens of interviews, because I approach topics as a journalist and I want a clear idea of how the ordinary reader approaches a topic. Then I outline laboriously, my outlines almost as long as the chapters. The outlining takes care of the left-brain, logical-sequence stage, yet when I actually start writing the outline gets lost in the dust. I find myself going in many directions, and later in the editing stage I have to go back and make major cuts; usually around 100 pages get cut from the final draft. That seems inefficient, I know. I wish I could write without the lengthy outlining process, and I wish I could anticipate in advance what portions will get cut, but I can’t. I have to go through that process with every book.
JOANNE: What is your latest book about? Any other book in the works?
YANCEY: What Good Is God? tells of experiences I had in my travels around the world, difficult places like Mumbai, India, the night of the terrorist attacks, and Virginia Tech University just after the crazed gunman, as well as thrilling places like modern China and South Africa. Half the chapters are set overseas, half in the U.S., and in each case I tell “the story behind the story” of what happened as I was invited to speak.
Yes, I do have another book in the works, so primitive at this stage that I’m not even sure how to talk about it, though it deals with the general area of Christians relating to a secular society around us.
JOANNE: Do you have anything else you would like to share with our writers?
YANCEY: I’m aware that the entire publishing world is in a great state of flux. Traditional publishers printed hard-copy books and shipped them to bricks-and-mortar stores. Now electronic outlets have introduced many ways for a writer to connect to a reader, and we don’t know what that will look like in twenty years, or even ten years. Bookstores are going out of business at an alarming rate. The act of reading itself is changing, from a lengthy immersion in a book to a multi-tasking sampling of words from several sources at once. I feel like I’ve lived through the golden age of publishing. However, if I were in my early twenties rather than my early sixties I would be very excited about the new opportunities. That’s for the next generation to work out. Good luck!
JOANNE: Thank you so much, Mr. Yancey, for joining us here and sharing your wisdom! I’m sure the FaithWriters’ folks will be blessed. I know I have been.
************************************************************************************************************
About Philip Yancey: Philip Yancey is author of twenty books, including What’s So Amazing About Grace and The Jesus I Never Knew. His books have won thirteen Gold Medallion Awards from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and have sold more than fifteen million copies. (Fearfully and Wonderfully Made, In His Image, and The Gift of Pain were co-authored with Dr. Paul Brand.) Christian bookstore managers selected The Jesus I Never Knew as the 1996 Book of the Year, and What’s So Amazing About Grace? won the same award in 1998. You can learn more about him at his website, PhilipYancey.com.
Related posts:













30 Comments until now.
Awesome interview. It’s comforting to know even an accomplished writer like Mr. Yancey can struggle with some of the same writing processes a newbie like me struggles with. He gave great advice, too. Thanks, Jo!
Great interview Jo. Got some much needed advice to help me along. I’m thanking Mr. Yancey for sharing with us despite his busy schedule.
Joanne, I love it that you found a question that hadn’t been asked before in the hundreds of interviews I’m sure that Mr. Yancey has done. I’m also thankful to him for giving writers that extra bit of encouragement and advice. Great interview!
I really liked what Mr. Yancey said about not holding back, giving it your all. This is a lesson I’m learning, because to hold back for me is actually a trust issue. God will give what is needed when it is needed. I have to trust that and use all he’s given.
What a great interview! Mr. Yancey is one of my favorite authors. I was profoundly moved by his book, “Soul Survivor,” which gave me the courage to not back off from nonfiction writing which seems to be my passion. I share his love of outlining, too! I just wish I could move on from it!! Ha….
This is a wonderful interview. We do need some honest, “scowling” editors to help us improve. Such good advice.
Very busy man! Great interview, Joanne.
It’s so true we all have our own individual approach to writing. I like to outline, wish I could outline more, but I really don’t know the story until I dive in.
Thank you, Mr. Yancy, for great words of wisdom. I’m in my early twenties (well, mid twenties anyway) and I am excited about the opportunities. Perhaps my greatest fear is failing to take advantage of them.
Great interview, Joanne and great advice from Mr. Yancy.
The only thing I would have to kinda disagree with him is that you can’t make money with a blog. I’ve made over a whole dollar on my blog so far, one penny over to be exact. And I’ve received at least $100 in books too. But I guess that’s splitting hairs.
My husband and I recently finished reading together Philip Yancey’s book “Disappointment With God” — a true eye-opener.”
If you read this book, I must caution you. He’s graphic in the way he describes how we become disappointed with God’s ‘seeming’ lack of personal communication. So don’t get bogged down in the middle, put the book down and say, “What use is prayer? God won’t answer anyway.” Read it clear to the end.
You will see that, regardless of our disappointments, faith is the key to what God requires of us. He is still there. He still cares. He still answers us – just rarely as we expect.
The points Mr Yancey makes as he takes us through overcoming our divine disappointments are, as I said before, eye-opening.
Great interview, Jo–with one of my favorite authors! And that sometimes he avoids writing gives me hope for myself yet!
What an enriching interview!
The morphing new era of publishing appears to present brighter opportunities than ever to unite author and reader. And the scope of those opportunities, for new talent, also seems much more democratic toward one’s age or connections. One aphorism tells us that not all that glitters is gold; but then again, for those who see the glitter, it may be from finding their own Golden Age.
Thank you, Philip, for your inside insight, and Joanne, for enabling it.
Hold nothing back. That statement really meant a lot to me. In my works in process, I’m guilty of feeling like I should save stuff for a later work, fearful that there won’t be an idea or inspiration down the road. Isn’t that limiting God? IF He has called me to write, then write I will and hold nothing back. Thank you Mr. Yancey for your awesome words of wisdom. And thank you Jo, for this incredible interview.
Wonderful interview! Thanks, Jo and Mr. Yancey. Many nuggets of wisdom to store away.
Great interview, Joanne! Thanks for sharing your writing experience, Mr. Yancy. Good to hear that I’m not the only one who does major edits! God bless.
Fantastic interview with an amazing author! Thank you, Joanne, and I love the questions you chose.
Thank you for sharing the wonderful interview, Joanne! I enjoy Mr. Yancy’s books, and the Bible study I participate in has read several of them and appreciate the insight he has given us through them.
Great interview!!!!!
I’ve followed Mr. Yancy’s writings since he was a columnist with Campus Life. His insights are so thought-provoking and I always come away with a new perspective. Thanks so much for this interview.
“I have a few, very few, trusted friends who will edit me with a scowl.”
Those friends are so valuable! My scowling critique partners make my work so much better. Recently, however, my mother added herself to the list of scowlers with some excellent criticism of her own, and the last of my encouragers bit the dust.
Thanks for the great interview, Joanne and Philip! Fearfully and Wonderfully Made is an amazing book that has stuck with me all these years since I’ve read it. I’ve had The Gift of Pain recommended to me, but didn’t realize it was co-authored by Yancy. I’ll have to check it out.
Wonderful interview! Enjoyed learning about his outline process.
Great interview, Jo.
I especially took in the part where Mr. Yancey talked about not holding back, something which I’ve personally struggled with.
Thank you for your time, Mr. Yancey. It’s much appreciated.
The scowls are of immense value, especially from a writers group.
I liked the part about 3 stages to writing and shifting to stage 1 or 3 if 2 is giving a block. Personally I find stage 3 MUCH more fun than stage 2–crafting words and tightening the writing is the enjoyable part.
Interesting part about the scowls. I have found them to be valuable to some extent, provided I’m getting enough encouragement to balance them out. (I have had to learn the hard way not to throw pearls before swine). But if you can find a good mix between the two, it does help you improve – especially when critiques are specific and to the point (not just a general “This confused me” or “I really liked it”).
Thanks for sharing all this great advice!
Since Phillip Yancey is one of my favorite Christian authors, I thoroughly enjoyed reading his interview! I am impressed by his willingness to share his writing experience with all of us, and knowing that he avoids writing at times by letting other things get in the way is both reassuring and motivating.
Thank you Joanne for this interview, and thank you Mr. Yancey for your time. I have admired Mr. Yancey’s work since I read “The Jesus I Never Knew”. I love his bold, honest, thought-provoking style.
I like Mr. Yancey’s writing because it is always thought-provoking. I was also impressed here that he didn’t see the changes in publishing as a negative but as a positive for new and up-and-coming authors.
I wish more well-known and respected authors would be so willing to embrace the new normal like he has and cheer on the little guy.
We won’t do it like previous generations, but we will make our mark because God’s creativity will always flourish in those who strive to be the best, whether POD published, traditionally published, or self-published.
Great interview!
Our church did an “In Home Bible Study” using Yancy’s book “What’s So Amazing About Grace”. Our group were amazed to realize what grace really is about. Darlene Lundeen, Billings, Mt
My brother recommended I might like this website. He was totally right. This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!